From Understanding to Belonging

Picture of Tony Zambito

Tony Zambito

Share This Post:

Why Feeling Understood Changes Our Relationships with Organizations, Experiences, and Communities

For much of my working life, I’ve helped organizations understand the people they serve. And one thing I’ve come to appreciate, particularly as my work has expanded beyond buyers into audiences and communities, is that there is a difference between being known and feeling understood.

In the early years of developing Buyer Personas, I was trying to get companies to look beyond what they knew about buyers and begin understanding why people made the decisions they did. What were they trying to accomplish? What was happening in their lives or organizations when a decision became necessary? What mattered to them that wasn’t necessarily apparent to the company trying to sell them something?

Those questions remain important to me. But as I’ve been working through what Human Understanding means and why I believe it deserves a more important place in how organizations think and make decisions, I’ve found myself drawn to another question. It’s one thing for an organization to develop a deeper understanding of people. It’s another for the people on the other side of that relationship to actually feel understood.

I’m beginning to believe that difference deserves more attention than we give it.

We Know a Great Deal About People

Organizations have become extraordinarily capable of collecting information about people. We know what customers buy, how frequently they buy, what they look at, what they ignore, and when they stop coming back. We know which employees participate in programs, how they respond to surveys, and what their performance records tell us. Cultural organizations can track attendance, ticket purchases, donations, and the frequency with which someone returns.

Artificial intelligence is making it possible to bring even more of that information together, recognize patterns, and draw conclusions that would have been difficult to reach only a few years ago. Much of this is genuinely useful. I wouldn’t suggest otherwise, particularly after spending so many years helping organizations make better use of what they learn about people.

But I keep coming back to a question the information itself cannot necessarily answer.

Does the person on the other side feel understood?

A company can know a great deal about a customer and still misunderstand what matters most to that person. An employer can have extensive information about an employee and still have little appreciation for what that person is trying to accomplish in their working life. A cultural organization can know that someone has attended six performances in the past year without understanding why those evenings mattered or what place they’ve come to occupy in that person’s life.

Knowing more can certainly help us understand more. But the two aren’t interchangeable, and neither guarantees that the person being studied experiences anything resembling understanding.

This is an important distinction because organizations tend to approach understanding from their own perspective. We want better information so we can make better decisions. We want to know why someone buys, participates, stays, leaves, or chooses one alternative over another. Those are legitimate questions, and answering them well can make an organization more effective.

But there’s another side to the relationship, and it’s the one I find myself circling back to. What does it actually mean to someone when an organization understands something important about them? Does it change how they see that organization, whether they trust it, or whether they want to participate?

I’ve become increasingly interested in those questions because they take Human Understanding somewhere beyond the acquisition of knowledge. They bring us into the experience of being understood.

When the Relationship Begins to Change

I saw the importance of understanding goals and circumstances throughout my work with buyers. When an organization genuinely understood what someone was trying to accomplish, it could begin to see why its own assumptions about that person were incomplete or simply wrong.

Sometimes the company believed buyers were primarily concerned about price when they were actually worried about the consequences of making a bad decision. Sometimes it believed a particular capability would be persuasive when the buyer was struggling with an entirely different problem. And sometimes the organization discovered that what it considered valuable had relatively little to do with what the buyer was trying to achieve.

Those discoveries mattered because they could change what the organization decided to do. That remains one of the principles I believe should be central to Human Understanding: understanding should have the ability to change the decision.

What I’ve been thinking about more recently is what happens on the other side when those decisions begin to reflect a genuine understanding of people.

Consider an employee who has spent years feeling that leadership doesn’t understand the challenges of doing the job. The organization may have conducted surveys, held meetings, and communicated its intentions repeatedly. But the employee’s experience is that decisions continue to be made without much appreciation for what actually happens in the course of a working day.

Then something changes. Leadership begins asking different questions, takes seriously what employees have been trying to explain, and makes a decision that reflects what it has learned. The decision may not solve every problem. It may not even be the decision everyone wanted. But something about the relationship can begin to change because people recognize that their circumstances have finally been understood.

I think that recognition matters more than organizations sometimes realize.

Feeling understood doesn’t mean always getting what we want. Nor does it mean that someone agrees with every interpretation we have of a situation. As I explored in my previous essay, understanding people also means understanding how they understand. We can recognize why someone sees a situation a particular way without necessarily agreeing that their interpretation is correct.

But when people recognize that their goals, circumstances, and ways of seeing the world have been taken seriously, the relationship has a different starting point. They’re no longer simply the subject of an organizational decision. Their understanding of the situation has had some influence on it.

That may not produce immediate loyalty, trust, or agreement. Those things develop through experience and can be lost through experience as well. But it can create the possibility of a relationship that feels less one-sided.

What Audiences Have Taught Me About Belonging

My work with JazzBuffalo and ArtsBuffalo has given me a different perspective on this, one I don’t think I could have gained from working with buyers alone.

When we produce a jazz performance, there’s a great deal of attention given to the artist, the music, the venue, and the quality of the experience. As there should be. People deserve an excellent performance, and the musicians deserve an audience that appreciates what they’re creating.

But over time, I’ve become just as interested in what happens around the performance.

People arrive and recognize someone they haven’t seen in a while. They introduce a friend to an artist they’ve been following. They return to a particular venue because they’ve come to enjoy not only the music but also the people they encounter there. They begin to recognize familiar faces, develop habits around certain events, and look forward to being part of something that has become a regular presence in their lives.

JazzMondays has given me a telling story of its own. A young couple started coming because they enjoyed the Great American Songbook on an outdoor rooftop patio. That was the whole reason, at first. Over time, their table grew. Friends joined them, then family, until the evening itself became the occasion, a reason to get together that had very little to do with simply hearing the music and everything to do with what that table had become for them.

I don’t think that was something we engineered. It was something that happened because the rooftop experience gave them a reason to keep showing up, and they built something out of it we couldn’t have put on a flyer.

What began as a decision to attend a performance became something more meaningful.

I’ve watched people who initially came because they recognized an artist begin returning for musicians they had never heard of. I’ve seen how a familiar room, a welcoming atmosphere, and the opportunity to share an experience with others can become part of why people come back. The music remains essential, but it is no longer the only thing connecting them to the experience.

And I’ve come to think that this tells us something important about the difference between attendance and belonging.

Attendance tells us that someone came. Returning tells us they found a reason to come again. Belonging is something else. It suggests a person has begun to see an experience, an organization, or a community as somewhere they have a place.

There’s also an important distinction here that I’ve come to appreciate. The young couple and their growing table weren’t necessarily developing a deeper relationship with JazzBuffalo as an organization. They were developing relationships with one another, and the experience we made possible became part of those relationships.

Our understanding of why people gather, what makes an experience welcoming, and what encourages them to return can influence the decisions we make. But what people create together within those experiences is their own.

I don’t think organizations can simply create belonging by declaring themselves welcoming or announcing that everyone belongs. Nor can they assume that because someone participates frequently, that person necessarily feels a sense of belonging. People can be regular customers, loyal employees, or frequent attendees without feeling particularly connected to the organization involved.

Belonging seems to develop through a combination of experiences, relationships, recognition, and a growing sense that being there matters to the person and that their presence matters to others.

That last part interests me. There’s a real difference between enjoying an experience and feeling like you’re part of it. And I suspect that being understood can play an important role in making that second thing possible.

Understanding Is Not the Same as Creating Belonging

I want to be careful here because it would be easy to turn this into another organizational formula. Understand people, make the experience relevant, encourage participation, and eventually they’ll feel they belong.

Human relationships don’t work quite that neatly.

Someone can feel understood by an organization without wanting a deeper relationship with it. A buyer may appreciate that a company understands the problem they’re trying to solve and still choose another supplier. An employee may feel genuinely heard and nevertheless decide that a different career opportunity is right for them. Someone may attend a wonderful concert, feel entirely welcome, and simply have other priorities the following weekend.

None of those outcomes necessarily means the understanding was inadequate.

This is where I believe Human Understanding has to resist becoming another way of persuading people to do what organizations want them to do. If understanding becomes valuable only when it produces a sale, improves retention, increases attendance, or generates greater participation, we risk returning to the very organizational perspective we’re trying to move beyond.

The deeper question is whether we understand what matters to people well enough to make better decisions about how we serve them, even when those decisions don’t produce the immediate outcomes we might prefer.

Sometimes that understanding leads to a stronger relationship. Sometimes it reveals that the organization isn’t particularly relevant to what someone is trying to accomplish. Sometimes it helps us recognize that people want a different kind of relationship than the one we’ve been trying to create.

Belonging, when it develops, is meaningful partly because it cannot be demanded. People decide for themselves where they feel connected, where they feel accepted, and where they want to invest their time and attention.

Organizations can influence the conditions in which that happens. They can pay attention to what people are trying to accomplish, understand the circumstances in which people make decisions, and become more aware of how people interpret the experiences they encounter. They can create opportunities for connection and recognize the importance of relationships that develop among people, not simply between people and the organization.

But they cannot decide, on someone’s behalf, that a sense of belonging has been achieved.

As I continue developing Human Understanding as an organizational discipline and competency, I’m finding that it raises questions that go well beyond how organizations gather information about people. It asks what happens when understanding begins to influence the way an organization behaves, the assumptions leaders are willing to reconsider, and the decisions they make about how to serve people.

These questions apply across business, employment, education, the arts, and communities, although the answers won’t always be the same. The relationship someone wants with an employer is different from the relationship they want with a technology supplier. Neither is quite like the relationship someone develops with a neighborhood, a cultural institution, or a community of people who share an interest.

That’s another reason I hesitate to treat belonging as an inevitable destination. Human Understanding should help us recognize those differences rather than impose one idea of a successful relationship on everyone.

For twenty-five years, my work with Buyer Personas has been grounded in understanding what people are trying to accomplish and why they make the decisions they do. That work taught me how consequential genuine understanding can be for organizations. My experiences with audiences and communities have added another dimension. They’ve helped me see how understanding can also matter to the people on the other side of those decisions, particularly when it contributes to relationships and experiences in which people recognize something meaningful for themselves.

I’m still thinking through where that leads, and I suspect there’s more to understand than I’ve accounted for here. But one distinction is becoming clearer to me.

An organization can know a great deal about the people it serves without those people ever feeling understood. And even when people do feel understood, the relationship that follows isn’t something an organization can determine. It belongs to the people involved.

Maybe that’s where belonging begins. Not with an organization’s desire to create loyalty, engagement, or participation, but with people discovering, through their own experiences, that this is somewhere they want to be.

And somewhere they feel they have a place.

Categories: